• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Mystic Island

Where Everyone Has a Story

  • Stories
  • News
  • Explore
    • Drive-in
    • Tour
    • Map
  • Shop
  • About

The Old Stone Church

Written by The Keeper Leave a Comment

The Stone Church has many mysteries surrounding it—including several about the Stone family (the caretakers who have watched over it for over a hundred years), but maybe these mysteries aren’t all merely the result of coincidence and bad luck. There may be an entity of true evil residing in the church.

Filed Under: Chapter One, Stone Church

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

More of this Story

  • The Newspaper
  • Stan the Man
  • Reflections, Echoes, and the Mechanical Shark
  • Thank-ya Very Much
  • Heads Up
  • Nocking the List: Chapter 1— No Balls
  • The Doppler Effect
  • Where Stars Go
  • With Drawn: Part 1 — Once Upon a Time
  • Salt and Lime
  • Beneath the Weeping Tree: Part 1 — The Notebook
  • Death Tours: Part 1 — Welcome to Death Watch
  • Auras: Part 1 — Mother Night
  • The Skeleton: Part 1 — A Stringless Marionette
  • The Old Stone Church: Part 1—The Church
  • Earworm: Part 1
  • The Umbrella
  • Howdy Neighbor
  • The Ring
  • A Very Unfriendly Vice: Part 1— Inside In
  • The Old Stone Church
  • The Book of Ira

People & Places

  • A Very Unfriendly Vice
  • Apartments
  • Auras
  • Beneath the Weeping Tree
  • Campground
  • Carl
  • Chapter One
  • Death Tours
  • Demon's Point
  • E.B. Richardson
  • Earworm
  • High School
  • Hospital
  • Howdy Neighbor
  • Ira
  • Jacob
  • Jail
  • Louis Ting
  • Marina
  • Max
  • Middle School
  • Newspaper
  • Nick
  • Nocking the List
  • Pizza Shop
  • Price House
  • Reflection, Echoes, and the Mechanical Shark
  • Shops
  • St. Sebastians & Cemetery
  • Stone Church
  • Stories
  • The Bar
  • The Skeleton
  • The Woods
  • Uncategorized
  • William
  • With Drawn

Copyright © 2026 Mystic Island · Design by NoWallsWeb · Log in